There is no single best time to get off the ship at Castaway Cay or Lookout Cay because the ideal schedule depends on the kind of day you want to have. For families who love the beach and island activities, arriving early in the morning is appealing because the water is calm and clear and there are plenty of open beach spots. Many cruisers who go ashore between 8:30 and 10 find that they can easily spend most of the day there. Families have reported staying from around 9 in the morning until after 3 in the afternoon without running out of things to do. The beaches feel lively in the morning but generally never feel overcrowded and become noticeably quieter in the early afternoon, especially after one o’clock.
For guests who prefer a slower pace, getting off the ship later can actually feel more enjoyable. Some families like to spend the morning eating breakfast at Cabanas, relaxing on their balcony, and enjoying the peace of a ship that feels partially empty. They often choose to go ashore closer to 10:30 or 11, once the initial rush has passed. This approach still allows several relaxed hours on the island, without the feeling of being pushed to get out the door early. It is a good option for people who want the atmosphere of the island without trying to participate in every activity or secure a specific spot.
There are also travelers who choose not to get off the ship at all, even on Castaway Cay days, and are very happy with that decision. Staying on board during a port day can feel like having access to a private resort. Pools are quiet, hot tubs are available, the AquaDuck and AquaMouse lines are shorter, and onboard dining areas feel restful. It can also be a great opportunity to take photos or simply enjoy the ship without crowds. Some cruisers say it is one of their favorite days of the trip because the ship feels so calm and spacious.
Crowds on the island follow a fairly predictable pattern. Mornings are the busiest, especially before lunch. Midday becomes more spread out, and afternoons are often surprisingly quiet, particularly after lunch when many families return to the ship. Food is served on the island, usually between 11:30 and 2, and it is convenient to grab lunch ashore, although the lines can get long at peak times. Families with young children generally do better getting off early because it allows time to play in cooler morning sun before nap schedules, hunger, or heat catch up with everyone.
Adults who plan to spend time at Serenity Bay will find it peaceful at most times of day. It is especially calm in the afternoon when many families head back to the ship. Couples and groups of adults often describe Serenity Bay as a highlight and appreciate when it is quiet enough to read, nap, or enjoy a drink by the water.
Whether you choose to race off the ship at 8:30, wander ashore closer to noon, or enjoy the ship all day, you will find that Castaway Cay and Lookout Cay provide plenty of ways to relax and have fun. The only real mistake is feeling pressured to follow someone else’s schedule. If you pick a pace that suits your family, there is a very good chance you will look back and feel like you used the day exactly as you should have.
