Many guests wonder if a day at Lookout Cay or Castaway Cay is worth it if they cannot reserve or afford one of the private cabanas. The short answer is yes. Most people on the island do not have a cabana, and they still have a great time. Cabanas are limited, highly popular, and priced for only a small percentage of cruisers. Depending on the sailing, they can range from around $600 to over $1,500 for the day, so it is completely normal to skip them.
Without a cabana, you still have access to the same beautiful beaches, warm clear water, and island activities. Many families start the day swimming, relaxing on lounge chairs, and playing in the sand. Lookout Cay has a family splash pad area that is refreshing on hot days and especially fun for younger kids who want shallow water play. Older kids often wander to the youth club area, such as Sebastian Cove, for games and supervised activities designed just for them.
Food is included, and both islands serve a casual barbecue style lunch. A good strategy is to arrive before 12:30pm to avoid longer lines, especially on busy sailings. The kids clubs serve lunch as well, so children who are checked in can eat there without leaving the activities. Adults without kids frequently spend time at the family beach and then transition to the adult only areas for a quiet afternoon.
There are also options for guests sailing solo. You can spend time at the family beach to people watch, take a swim, or read. Later, you can head to the adult beach to relax in a peaceful setting away from the music and splash zones. Lunch at the barbecue is simple but satisfying, and there are plenty of shaded picnic tables available.
The islands are designed so that guests can enjoy the entire experience without paying extra for private spaces. A cabana is a luxury add on, not a necessity for having fun. If you focus on swimming, exploring, eating, and enjoying the scenery, you will likely walk away with the same tired and happy feeling as everyone else.
